Home
Register Lost Password About

  Latest All Misc Space Science Computers Models Fiction 3D Printing Math
Taxation - in human scale.

83 views  0 comments  1 likes  0 followers

You must be logged in to like, follow, purchase items, or to add comments.

Click either 'Login' or 'Register', above.

Taxation, reduced to human scale.

Take the cost of something government does, divide by the number of taxpayers, put big numbers into human-scales.

 
Huexotzinco Codex, 1531 (courtesy of WikiCommons) part of a legal document that resulted in the King of Spain returning 2/3rds of the taxes collected on the Nahua Indian people in the town of Huexotzinco.

So, there are approximately 120 million US tax payers. Their income taxes are around 40% of all Federal income — and the payroll taxes paid by their employers represent another 40%. So if we take various large amounts of federal spending and divide it by 120,000,000 we can reduce these crazy large numbers to something we can understand at human scales.

So, for example — funding for the NASA human spaceflight work is $6 billion over 5 years — and congress recently cut their $830 million budget to $560 million — which means that SpaceX won’t get enough funding to finish their space taxi until after the ISS gets so old it’ll have to be abandoned. Sounds like we saved a ton of money on that one!

But reduce it to human scale (divide the numbers by 120 million) and it emerges that this project is costing me, personally, $50 over 5 years…which easily passes my “less than a cup of coffee per month” test. I’d prefer that the world had a successful commercial manned space program than I need that monthly caffeine fix.

OK — so that one’s easy. Let’s grab a pie chart with some federal spending numbers and see where this goes…

 

The total spending by our government is $3,504 billions…which is…holy crap! $29,200 of my money!! Ouch! But wait, only 40% of that is my income taxes — the rest is mostly paid by my employer in payroll taxes…so it’s only about $11,700 out of MY paycheck.

$2,800 of my money goes into social security…about the same goes into healthcare…woaahhh — I spend $2,000 a year on the military! I spend $763 a year on interest payments on the debt we owe…and $3,343 on other “stuff”.

“Other” stuff? Well, the “Mandatory” stuff is things like the departments of Agriculture, Education and Veterans Affairs…the “Discretionary” stuff is those mysterious and dubious-sounding earmarks, appropriations and pork.

Evidently, I spend $766 per year of my money on “transportation” — kinda hope we can mend some potholes and fix the occasional collapsing bridge for that much. I think I might want to kick in a bit more for that.

Hmmm…so what about Education? What’s that costing me? Well, $500 out of my income taxes…but also $2,300 (per taxpayer) in state funding and another $4,500 out of local taxes…so $7,300 a year. That sounds like a lot — but it costs $12,000 per year to educate a kid to US standards — so if you currently have even one child in school, this is a bargain! Of course if you don’t have kids…not so much so. Well I guess we really don’t want a bunch of uneducated people running around the place pushing up that $2,800 we spend on social security and reducing the number of tax payers so I’d be on the hook to pay a bigger share. So I guess the education bill isn’t so terrible.

So what does the federal debt look like right now? $18.6 trillion…which means that my share of the debt is $155,000?! Yikes! That’s a mortgage! But evidently I’m paying interest on that mortgage at only $763 per *year*?! That’s like a tenth of what I’d be paying a bank on a 30 year mortgage. We’re never going to pay it off at this rate!

So, businesses pay around $191 billion in income taxes…which means that they’re only contributing $636 compared to my $11,000 tax bill? That doesn’t sound fair.

Bottom line here: When you hear a big number of federal dollars, mentally divide it by 120,000,000 and think “What if I have to pay that much for it?”

As a shortcut: A trillion dollars = $10,000 of your taxes — scary money, worry a lot about this! A billion dollars = $10 of your yearly taxes — so the odd few billions here and there isn’t so terrible — but hundreds of billions is something to pay attention to. Anything the government does that’s expressed in “millions” fails the “cost of a cup of coffee” test and may safely be ignored.

Reader Forum: Taxation - in human scale.

You must be logged in to add comments.

Click either 'Login' or 'Register', above.